Budapest or Bust

I never met my paternal grandparents; they died several years before my birth.  I pieced together snippets of their lives in the way that young children do, comprehending little, listening intermittently.

They were immigrants.  My grandfather came to New York as a child from Sweden.  I don’t remember if he had any siblings.  The men I remember seeing at my father’s funeral might have been uncles or cousins.  I never thought to ask then.  It didn’t really matter.  My father was dead.  What I didn’t realize, nor could’ve comprehended at the  fragile age of 13, was that I lost more than him when that funeral procession ended.  I lost contact with practically everyone with a key to me understanding my history.

My grandfather was a judge, and mayor of a town in the metro-Miami area.   The city named a baseball field after him.   That is literally all I know of him.  My father’s only sister and I write occasionally and I ask her to recall, but her long-term memory is punctured by confusion and anger of being disowned for her sexuality, memories of a tragic car accident which killed her mother, severe epilepsy and harsh medications.

Of all the knowledge that she has lost, I most value extracting the  fragmented memories of her mother.  Because truly, it’s my grandmother’s legacy that intrigues.

My grandmother was an immigrant too.  She came through Ellis Island with her older sister, Ashie-Pattle, and their mother.  They came from Hungary.  Their last name was some variant of Balint, which I understand means Valentine in Hungarian.  One of my earliest memories was my mom talking with Ashie-Pattle about how their mother had returned to Hungary to visit and became trapped when the Iron Curtain fell and how she had died there.

Imagine being six years old.  Now imagine believing that your great-grandmother had been crushed by a metal curtain.  Imagine envisioning her dying under the weight of this curtain.  Would you have asked more questions?  Because I didn’t.  I explored the horror soley in my dreams.  Only to discern years later, as an adult in my early twenties, that the reality was a much less gruesome and yet much more devastating dichotomy.

My Great Aunt Ashie-Pattle lived in town, undoubtedly obliged  to leave New York when she became widowed. The small cottage in rural Florida suited her well enough,   I imagine she felt comfort being close to her sister and her Swedish-judge-mayor-brother-in-law.  She loved watching televised women’s tennis matches , fed me my black coffee when I was nine, kept stockpiles of condensed milk and relied on my mother and I to pick her up and take her to physicians visits and the grocery store.

At some point I learned that she’d has a distinguished career as a professional dancer, travelling and performing with her late husband Ned.  They had toured and danced with Fred Astaire and Ginger Rogers.  She was still limber and petite into her 80′s.  I would beg her to show me dance steps and she did, with unfounded grace.  She always wore her jet-black dyed hair braided  in a bun with red lipstick and pristine polyester suits from the fifties.  She would spend an hour getting ready for a five-minute walk outside.   She was proud.  She was secretive.  My father’s whole family seemed this way.  Possibly more-so because I knew so little.   Like my Aunt Margot, Ashie-Pattle had severe epilepsy but hid it with keen fervor.  Because in her culture epileptics were deemed possessed by the devil and banished to asylums.  She never once mentioned her medications by name.  My mother would have to take doctors aside and show them the pill bottles in secret, because she simply would never speak of it.  She lived this glorious charade until she fell outside the cottage one day, broke her hip and went to live out her remaining days without a dab of lipstick or a shred of dignity in a nursing home where the only thing they payed mind to were her secret pills.  I have to wonder if the stigma she feared was less of being perceived as possessed, and more of being perceived as nothing but “disabled”.  I found a small solace when I recently stumbled upon her archived obituary online, and noted that it listed her solely as “Dancer.”

In 634 words that is essentially all I know of my father’s family.  There are so many secrets I never learned and so many questions about myself, my global identity, that remain unanswered.

In my mid-20′s I sometimes traveled internationally  for work.  It was around this time that I became intent upon making a journey to Hungary.  I thought, “if anything, I will walk the streets of Budapest and sit by the Danube as my ancestors had.  I will walk in the footprints of time and maybe, just maybe, stumble upon the truth.  The truth about my family and the truth about me.”

At that time in my life Budapest also symbolized a coming of age, a coming into independence and adulthood.  In the spring of 2004, I planned to travel alone by train, from a conference I was attending in Vienna, Austria.  I insisted on planning this journey on my own, on seeing it through all by myself.  I needed to do this.  I needed to prove that I could travel internationally on my own, to a country where I shared nothing in common but 1/4 of my blood.

I wondered what it was like to go through Ellis Island as a child, to start over with nothing in New York City and build a new life.  To learn a new language, and get an education, and marry, and have children.  To move to Florida as a mayor’s wife.  To travel the country with the most famous dance troupe of all time.

Surely if they could do that.  I could manage to get off at the right train stop, read a map, and keep myself fed for a few days.

It was so much more than a trip to Budapest.  So very much more.

And at the very last moment; I didn’t go.

In short, I caved to someone elses’ will.  I lacked the self-respect and dignity it would’ve taken to put myself first.

I hated myself for not going for a very long time.  I hated myself for being weak.  I hated myself for letting someone elses’ opinion of my ability overrule what I knew as truth.

I could’ve done it.  I could’ve traveled to Budapest by myself.  I could’ve answered some questions, if not about my ancestry, then at the very least about my own fortitude.

The iron curtain fell and I was on the wrong side of it.

Today I think about Budapest in a more existential way.  It’s not a trip I’d like to make.  It is a journey I must complete.

It is my Ellis Island.

This time, the trip is about fulfilling that coming of age that has and will continue to elude me.

I must go to Budapest and I must go alone.  If I don’t get on the train this time, I will only have myself to blame.

So I’m saving up.  I figure I can put away five dollars a week for the next ten years  and I can find my way back to that train station, back to those crossroads of my symbolic quest for identity.

Only this time, stepping off the train is merely evidence that I’ve already found all the answers I need.

Be Sociable, Share!

11 thoughts on “Budapest or Bust

  1. This is achingly beautiful. I hope you get to make the journey anyway, to connect with parts of your family history. But it sounds like you’ve already found your identity…and it is strong.

  2. This is beautiful. I can relate to it on so many levels. I know very little about my dad’s side of the family. My grandfather came from Austria and would never talk about the “old Country”. And my grandma died when i was 2. I can’t quite explain it, but it has always bothered me that I didn’t know my grandma. Maybe it was because my mom’s side of the family wasn’t too warm and there was alcoholism running rampant. I guess I always figured Grandma Charlotte would have been the one to really love me (because the stories say she was amazingly warm and loving). That’s why I named my daughter after her, after a woman I never knew, but who somehow represents something important to me. I can’t explain it.

    Anyway, I can also relate to letting someone else talk me out of something important.

    You save that money and take that trip!

  3. You are an AMAZING writer. I had goosebumps the whole way through. My dad died at 13, too, but he has five brothers and sisters and because genealogy is so big in my religion, I know a lot about everyone. I can not imagine not knowing.

    You will go. Hopefully it will be sooner than 10 years. Hopefully there are people who can help you on your way.

    And when you do, you have to write a book about it. You. Have. To. I didn’t want this post to end.

  4. I relate to so much of what you long for in this post. A sense of history and longing to uncover what is lost to us by the passing of a generation. It seems a wistful, lonely piece of writing, beautifully put. I ache to tear down the many boundaries set out in this post from the Iron Curtain to the prejudices of an ignorant culture that caused shame to a beautiful dancer, shame that never should have existed.

    I too want to know my family history. Half is Swedish – like yours- and my grandfather came to Idaho from Sweden. My mother’s family is a complete mystery as she left North Korea just before the war broke out to live with her aunt in the South and left behind her mom, dad and 5 brothers and sisters. I know nothing of that side of the family or how my mom lived for 4-5 years in the South until she came to America.

    It is a shame that you did not make that trip when you wanted to do so. I wonder if we can really find what we are looking for when we see, feel, smell and touch those things in a location or it is not meant to be or a border that has changed so the past becomes nothing more than illusion.

    Wonderful, thoughtful post. I await your second part – when you tell us how the trip went.

  5. Loved this post, I can relate to the strong desire to know your family’s history and I’d love to hear about your experiences when you finally get to make that journey.

  6. This is exquisite writing.
    I am sure you will get there, and that it will be exactly the kind of journey you hope it will be.
    My grandfather (the only grandfather I knew as the others all died before I was born) was not actually my biological grandfather. He was my paternal grandmother’s second husband. He was Hungarian. I adored him, he adored us all. He migrated to Australia in the 1950s and he had a number tattooed on the inside of his right forearm, indicating his time as a prisoner in a work camp before he escaped and became a refugee.
    I can appreciate your longing for the connection to your family that can only be found through a place. Good luck with this journey. And thank you for sharing it with us.

  7. Pingback: Uncle | Everybody's Boy

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>